† Corresponding author. E-mail:
Project supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 11775176), the Basic Research Program of Natural Science of Shaanxi Province, China (Grant No. 2018KJXX-094), the Key Innovative Research Team of Quantum Many-Body Theory and Quantum Control in Shaanxi Province, China (Grant No. 2017KCT-12), and the Major Basic Research Program of Natural Science of Shaanxi Province, China (Grant No. 2017ZDJC-32).
We study the relations between solitons of nonlinear Schrödinger equation and eigen-states of linear Schrödinger equation with some quantum wells. Many different non-degenerated solitons are re-derived from the eigen-states in the quantum wells. We show that the vector solitons for the coupled system with attractive interactions correspond to the identical eigen-states with the ones of the coupled systems with repulsive interactions. Although their energy eigenvalues seem to be different, they can be reduced to identical ones in the same quantum wells. The non-degenerated solitons for multi-component systems can be used to construct much abundant degenerated solitons in more components coupled cases. Meanwhile, we demonstrate that soliton solutions in nonlinear systems can also be used to solve the eigen-problems of quantum wells. As an example, we present the eigenvalue and eigen-state in a complicated quantum well for which the Hamiltonian belongs to the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian having parity–time symmetry. We further present the ground state and the first exited state in an asymmetric quantum double-well from asymmetric solitons. Based on these results, we expect that many nonlinear physical systems can be used to observe the quantum states evolution of quantum wells, such as a water wave tank, nonlinear fiber, Bose–Einstein condensate, and even plasma, although some of them are classical physical systems. These relations provide another way to understand the stability of solitons in nonlinear Schrödinger equation described systems, in contrast to the balance between dispersion and nonlinearity.
Solitons have been found in many different physical systems,[1–5] such as bright soliton, dark soliton, breather-like solitons, and abundant vector solitons. The prototypical model for the study of these solitons is the nonlinear Schrödinger (NLS) equation with attractive or repulsive interactions. Many experiments suggested that the NLS model described well the evolution dynamics of many different nonlinear systems, such as water wave tank,[6] optical fiber,[7] Bose–Einstein condensate,[8] etc. It is noted that the nonlinear terms can be understood as some certain quantum potentials.[9–12] If the density profiles depend on time, the NLS evolution corresponds to linear Schrödinger (LS) with time-dependent quantum wells. It is also difficult to solve LS with time-dependent quantum wells, therefore we focus on the eigen-problems of LS with time-independent potentials. If the density profile of nonlinear term is time-independent, the potentials will also become time-independent, and the NLS can be related with the eigen-problems of LS with the quantum potentials.[10,11] This provides possibilities to establish correspondence relations between soliton states and the eigen-states in quantum wells. The relations are nontrivial to be established because they enable us to obtain more abundant dynamics of localized waves in nonlinear systems,[13] and solve the eigen-problems in more complicated quantum wells. They also provide possibilities to investigate the evolution of quantum states in classical nonlinear systems.
In this paper, we study the quantitative relations between solitons of NLS equation with attractive or repulsive interactions and eigen-states of LS equation with quantum wells. The discussions are made on static solions for simplicity. It should be noted that soliton with velocities can be related with static soliton through Galilean transformation because the NLS equations admit Galilean symmetry. Therefore, the relations also hold well for solitons with velocities, just as the Galilean transformation holds. We start from the simplest scalar NLS with attractive interaction to establish the relation, and then generalize it to multi-component NLS cases with attractive interactions. Especially, we show that vector solitons in multi-component NLS with repulsive interaction can be generated from the eigen-problem in identical quantum wells for NLS with attractive interactions. We establish the explicit relations up to general N-component coupled case, and the results are summarized in Table
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Section
With dimensionless unit, the simplest NLS equation can be written as follows:
We will then discuss two cases: the attractive interaction and repulsive interaction cases. For N-component coupled NLS with attractive interactions, we can derive many different soliton solutions from the eigen-states in some certain quantum wells. The discussion begins with the well-known bright soliton of the simplest scalar NLS equation with attractive interaction. For N-component coupled NLS with repulsive interactions, we can derive many different soliton solutions from the identical eigen-states with the attractive cases. We discuss them started with the well-known dark soliton of the simplest scalar NLS equation with repulsive interaction. Our results will show that vector solitons for coupled NLS with attractive interactions and repulsive interactions can be generated from identical quantum wells, and they admit identical eigenvalues of the quantum wells. It should be noted that soliton with velocities can be related with static soliton through Galilean transformation because the NLS equations admit Galilean symmetry. Therefore, we discuss the subject mainly based on static solitons.
It should be emphasized that many of the following soliton solutions have been obtained by some other methods (Darboux transformation, Hirota bilinear forms, and other methods), and even many similar solutions have been given in Refs. [10], [11], [13], and [14]. But we would like to re-derive them and describe how to generate these soliton solutions in details, to show the unified properties of solitons clearly. The parameters of soliton solutions are also written in a different way from the ones in Refs. [11], [13], and [14] to show their physical meaning more clearly and demonstrate the unified characters of solitons more conveniently.
For γ = 1 attractive case, the fundamental soliton solution of the NLS is
We have studied vector soliton in multi-component coupled NLS equations. The component number can be very large and marked by N. Then the N-component coupled NLS equation can be written as
From the eigen-state
The eigenvalues and eigen-states for the quantum well
The eigen-states correspond to
Therefore, we must introduce some new coefficients for them: namely,
From the knowledge that more bound states can emerge for much deeper potential well,[17] we can obtain more bound states though making the quantum well deeper. Therefore we introduce a multiply factor h to the quantum well, namely,
The eigen-states correspond to
Then, we investigate the N = 4 case. Let ψj(x,t) = ϕj(x) e−iμjt and
It should be pointed that the above results are identical with the results in Ref. [11]. Here we demonstrate more clearly that the solitons of NLS can be related with the eigen-state in
For γ = −1 repulsive case, the fundamental soliton solution of the NLS is
Comparing with the
Form the results for the quantum well
Therefore we must introduce some new coefficients for them, namely,
Similar to the attractive case for more eigen bound states, we further deep the potential well
In a similar way, we can obtain the vector soliton in the four-component coupled NLS with repulsive case as follows from further deepened potential well
Furthermore, we establish the correspondence between non-degenerated solitons and eigen-states in the quantum well
It should be pointed out that many soliton solutions re-derived from the eigen-states have been presented by Darboux-transformation, Hirota bilinear method, which usually admits sech1(x) form even for the multi-component coupled cases. Also we emphasize that many multi-soliton complexes have been given in Refs. [11] and [14], which were also derived from the solutions of a LS with adding some constrain conditions. But the correspondence between eigen-states of LS and NLS with attractive or repulsive interactions were not addressed systemically. In particular, we show that solitons of the arbitrary N-component NLS with repulsive interactions have identical eigenvalues with the ones of N-component NLS with attractive interactions. Furthermore, there is a special character for dark solitons of N-component NLS with both attractive and repulsive interactions, namely, they always correspond to the zero energy eigenvalue in the quantum well, with a proper reference for which the free plane wave admits zero kinetic energy. These underlying characters have not been uncovered clearly in the previous studies, and they enable us to obtain soliton solutions of N-component coupled NLS with repulsive interactions from the ones in NLS with attractive interactions. It is well known that Darboux transformation forms are different for the NLS with repulsive and attractive interactions.[20] Some authors have even tried to derive dark solitons by Hirota method,[21,23] or the KP-hierarchy reduction method.[24] Therefore, these underlying characters are non-trivial and enable us to derive vector solitons more conveniently. Based on the non-degenerated soliton presented above, we can obtain very abundant vector solitons directly; such as degenerated solitons and beating solitons.
From the above non-degenerated soliton solution, we know that the soliton solution of M-component coupled NLS equation can be used to construct much abundant vector solitons in N-component coupled cases with N > M. Obviously, larger M component number will generate more abundant vector soliton types. As an example, we show explicitly how many vector solitons for 4-component coupled cases can be generated from the 3-component cases.
There are mainly three different cases for degenerated soliton in 4-component NLS which are generated from the non-degenerated solitons in three-component NLS because there are at most two degenerated components in this case. First, if there are two components degenerated in the fundamental state, then the vector solitons for the repulsive interaction case can be written as
It is well-known that the arbitrary linear superposition of eigen-states of LS equation with the quantum well is still the solution of the LS equation. Therefore the linear superposition of the above non-degenerated and degenerated soliton solutions will also be used to generated localized waves. However, there are some constrain conditions on the superposition coefficients for the NLS equation because the effective potential in NLS depends on the wave functions. The linear superposition forms are generated from these eigen-states, but they demonstrate striking dynamics characters. The beating dark-dark soliton was obtained by the similar SU(2) symmetry.[29,30] Based on the above results, we know that the beating effects are induced by the eigenvalue difference between the solitons.[31] In fact, this simple idea can be used to generated very abundant localized waves with beating effects. Explicitly, N-component coupled NLS with equal nonlinear coefficients admits SU(N) symmetry, and the related unitary matrix can be used to construct beating solitons. Especially, the forms of unitary matrix can be chosen to admit SU(M) (M ≤ N) symmetry, which enables us to obtain very abundant different beating patterns.[31]
These solutions are all derived from the eigen-states in quantum wells. The corresponding relations deep our understanding on the eigenvalues of solitons and the relations between solitons in attractive and repulsive interaction cases. Then, we would like to show that the soliton solution of NLS could also help us to obtain eigen-state and eigenvalues in more complicated quantum wells.
We consider the following LS equation with a more complicated well
Moreover, the asymmetric soliton solution of the coupled NLS reported in Ref. [41] can be used to construct eigen-states of an asymmetric quantum double-well. For example, we show a simple case to present the ground state and the first exited state in an asymmetric quantum double-well. The corresponding quantum well admits the following form:
A systemic relation is established between the eigen-state in quantum wells and the soliton solution of multi-component coupled NLS with attractive or repulsive interactions. It is shown that static soliton excitation of N-component coupled nonlinear Schödinger equation corresponds to the first N eigen-states in a
Abundant degenerated solitons can be derived directly from the non-degenerated soliton solutions. Degenerated soliton for N-component coupled NLS with attractive or repulsive interactions can be generated from the non-degenerated solitons of M-component coupled NLS, even with N > M. Moreover, the linear superposition principle in quantum mechanics can be used to construct very abundant vector solitons with beating effects in the systems with some certain constrain conditions on the superposition coefficients. The beating behavior of solitons can also be extended to the high-dimensional systems.[42–44]
Although these soliton solutions are all static, the related solitons with velocities can be obtained directly by Galilean transformation for the NLS equations admit Galilean symmetry. We emphasize that the analytical solution describing interactions between these solutions can not be derived from the eigen-states in quantum wells. But these solitons with different velocities can be chosen as the initial states to simulate soliton interaction numerically because when solitons are well separated, they can be seen as the linear superposition of solitons with different velocities approximately.[45,46] For example, the collisions between solitons with nodes were investigated in Ref. [47], which demonstrated that they were robust to collisions and even noises. Additionally, a complicated method was proposed to study the collision of these solitons with nodes analytically,[41] with the aid of results in Ref. [10]. However, we have not discussed this subject in this paper. As far as we know, the solitons with more than one nodes have not been derived by the well-known Darboux transformation method,[15,16,20] Hirota bilinear method,[19,21,23] and even other methods.[24] Some of our results are similar to the soliton solutions with more than one nodes presented before,[11,14] which were also generated from the eigen-states of LS. However, we focus on the correspondence relations between solitons in nonlinear systems and eigen-states in quantum wells. The degenerated solitons or beating solitons generated from the eigen-states have not been addressed systemically before either.
We also demonstrate that soliton solution of nonlinear partial equation can be used to solve the eigen-problems of quantum wells. As an example, we present an eigenvalue and its eigen-state in a complicated quantum well for which the Hamiltonian belongs to the non-Hermitian Hamiltonian having parity–time symmetry. We further present the ground state and the first exited state in an asymmetric quantum double-well from asymmetric solitons. This paves the ways to solve the LS with complicated potentials with the aid of well-developed techniques for solving NLS equations. This is very meaningful for LS with more complicated quantum wells which is hard to be solved directly because the exact solutions of LS equation with different potentials play an important role in mathematics and physics.[48–50] These relations suggest that the stability of soliton states is related with the evolution of eigen-states in quantum wells directly. The stability of moving solitons can also be understood by the eigen-states in moving localized quantum wells. This provides another way to understand the stability of solitons in NLS described systems.
As an example, we discuss the possibilities to observe these quantum states in BEC systems.[51] Soliton interactions in BEC systems have been demonstrated widely in real experiments.[52–55] The experimental techniques can be used to produce the initial conditions for observing these soliton states, and the bound states or quasi-bound states have been widely shown to be robust. Very recently, a dark-bright-bright soliton was experimentally demonstrated in spinor BEC systems.[56] It is noted that the dark soliton component admits one node and the two bright soltion components admit identical eigen-state and they are degenerated. Therefore the observed solitons correspond to the degenerated soliton case here. In fact, the vector soliton in the three-component coupled systems can admit non-degenerated solitons which are presented above. The dark soliton in one component can admit a double-valley structure, and one bright soliton component can also admit a node which makes the bright soliton admit double-hump. These are quite different from the ones observed in Ref. [56]. Therefore, the results here predict much more abundant soliton profiles in the coupled NLS described systems.[57] Many different types of beating solitons were also demonstrated and more beating patterns were expected.[31] The results here can be used to construct more exotic beating solitons with the help of symmetry properties. The evolution of quantum states could be observed in some classical systems, such as nonlinear fiber, water wave tank, etc. because the NLS describe many different classical systems[58] and a generalized hydrodynamics could provide a remarkable quantum–classical equivalence.[59]
[1] | |
[2] | |
[3] | |
[4] | |
[5] | |
[6] | |
[7] | |
[8] | |
[9] | |
[10] | |
[11] | |
[12] | |
[13] | |
[14] | |
[15] | |
[16] | |
[17] | |
[18] | |
[19] | |
[20] | |
[21] | |
[22] | |
[23] | |
[24] | |
[25] | |
[26] | |
[27] | |
[28] | |
[29] | |
[30] | |
[31] | |
[32] | |
[33] | |
[34] | |
[35] | |
[36] | |
[37] | |
[38] | |
[39] | |
[40] | |
[41] | |
[42] | |
[43] | |
[44] | |
[45] | |
[46] | |
[47] | |
[48] | |
[49] | |
[50] | |
[51] | |
[52] | |
[53] | |
[54] | |
[55] | |
[56] | |
[57] | |
[58] | |
[59] |